Is hipages worth it? Lead sites versus your own website

Lead platforms are not a scam and they are not free money either. The question is what a job actually costs you through one, and whether that number gets better or worse over time.

How lead sites actually work

You pay for access to job enquiries. Depending on the platform and the plan, that is either a subscription, a credit system where each lead costs credits, or a mix of both.

The part that catches people out is that a lead is not a job. The same enquiry usually goes to several trades at once. You pay to be one of the names in the running, not the one who gets the work.

So the real number is not the cost per lead. It is the cost per lead divided by your conversion rate. If a lead costs you twenty dollars and you win one in four, each job you land carries eighty dollars of lead cost before you have picked up a tool.

Do the maths on a job

Pull your last three months of platform invoices and work out three numbers.

  1. Total spent. Subscription plus any credits or per lead charges.
  2. Jobs actually won from those leads. Not quotes sent. Jobs invoiced.
  3. Total revenue from those jobs.

Divide the spend by the jobs won and you have your true cost per job. Divide that by your average job value and you have the percentage of each job going to the platform.

Under ten percent, and it is probably working for you. Over twenty five, and you are running a marketing channel that owns the customer relationship while you carry the risk.

Count the quoting time too If you are driving out to quote jobs you win one in five of, that is four unpaid trips for every one that pays. Fuel and hours are part of the cost per job even though they never show up on the invoice.

Where they genuinely make sense

There are situations where lead sites are the right call, and it is worth being honest about them.

  • You are brand new. No reviews, no reputation, no rankings. Lead sites give you work while you build those things. Use them to get reviews, not just revenue.
  • You have a quiet patch to fill. Turning spend on for a month to plug a gap is a sensible use of the tool.
  • You are entering a new area or trade. Cheaper than advertising blind into a suburb where nobody knows you.
  • Your close rate is genuinely good. Some trades convert at one in two because they answer the phone fast and quote on the spot. At that rate the economics work fine.

The structural problem

The issue is not the price. It is that the cost per job never improves, and you never accumulate anything.

Every lead is bought fresh. Stop paying and it stops, the same week. Three years of spend leaves you with no asset, no audience and no search presence. The platform holds the customer relationship and the reviews.

You are also competing on speed and price against four other trades who got the same enquiry. That pressure is built into the model. It is fine occasionally, and corrosive as a permanent way of working.

Renting leads is a cost that recurs forever. Owning a website is a cost that mostly ends.

What your own website does differently

A website is slower to start and it compounds. That is the whole difference.

  • The enquiry comes to you alone. No other trade got the same form submission. Your close rate on those is usually far higher than on shared leads.
  • It works with your Google profile. The map pack sends people somewhere, and the site is where they land and decide. See our guide to getting into the map pack.
  • It catches your referrals. Word of mouth still googles you before ringing. If nothing comes up, you lose jobs you had already won.
  • The cost stops. Build once, pay hosting and maintenance. Year two costs a fraction of year one.
  • You own the reviews and the content. Nobody can change the terms or raise the rate.

The honest downside is that it does not work on day one. Getting found takes weeks to months, which is exactly why the two things pair well.

Side by side

  • Time to first job. Lead site, days. Website, weeks to months.
  • Cost pattern. Lead site, forever and per job. Website, mostly upfront then small.
  • Competition on each enquiry. Lead site, three to five trades. Website, just you.
  • Who owns the customer. Lead site, the platform. Website, you.
  • What you have after three years. Lead site, invoices. Website, an asset that still brings in work.

On pure cost over three years it is rarely close. A build at $1,490 to $8,999 plus a few hundred a year in running costs is often less than a single year of steady lead spend. We broke the running costs down in what a website actually costs in Australia.

The answer for most trades is both

Not forever, and not evenly. Use the platform for what it is good at, and spend the time it buys you building the thing that lasts.

  1. Keep the lead spend on while you have nothing else bringing in work. Do not cut it out of principle.
  2. Get every one of those customers to leave a Google review. That is the real return on the spend, and it is the thing the platform cannot take back. Here is how to ask without it being awkward.
  3. Sort the Google Business Profile out. Free, and for most trades it outperforms the paid leads within a few months.
  4. Get a website that takes the call when those people go looking for you.
  5. Then wind the spend down, a bit at a time, watching where the work comes from.

Plenty of trades end up keeping a small amount of lead spend permanently for quiet weeks. That is a reasonable place to land. What you want to avoid is being five years in with the same cost per job and nothing of your own to show for it.

Working out the numbers on yours? Tell us your trade, your suburbs and roughly what you spend on leads. We will tell you honestly whether a website is likely to beat it, and what it would cost. Free, no pitch.

Skyfire Network

Western Sydney web design. Trade specialists, partner of Rated Tradies.