Wix, Squarespace or a custom website: what should you actually use?

Website builders are good now. For some businesses they are the right answer, and we will say so. Here is how to tell whether you are one of them.

The short version

If you are testing whether a business idea works, have no budget, and are happy to spend your own evenings on it, use a builder. If the website is meant to bring in work and you would rather be doing your actual job, pay someone to build it properly.

The rest of this is the detail behind that.

What builders do well

Wix, Squarespace and similar platforms have come a long way. They are a reasonable choice in a few situations.

  • Cheap to start. You pay a monthly plan instead of an upfront build. For a new business watching every dollar, that matters.
  • Fast to get something up. A weekend is enough for a basic site with your details on it.
  • Hosting and security handled. You do not need to think about servers or updates.
  • Easy edits. Changing your phone number or adding a photo takes a minute.

For a brand new ABN that needs to exist online, that is often enough to get going.

Where builders start to hurt

The problems usually show up once the site is meant to do more than sit there.

  • Speed. Builders load a lot of code to support every feature for every customer. On a phone over mobile data that can mean a slow first load, and slow sites lose people before they read anything.
  • Everyone looks the same. Templates are shared by thousands of businesses. Customers may not name it, but they notice when a site looks like every other one.
  • The time cost. The builder is cheap. Your hours are not. Most owners spend far longer on it than they planned and still end up with something they are not happy with.
  • Copy is still your job. A builder gives you the boxes. It does not tell you what to put in them, and the words are what actually get people to ring.
  • Leaving is awkward. Your design generally does not come with you if you move platforms. You rebuild from scratch.

What custom actually means

Custom does not have to mean expensive or complicated. It means the site is built for your business specifically, instead of adapted from a template.

In practice that is usually a handful of pages, written around what your customers ask before they hire someone, built to load quickly on a phone, with the technical SEO done properly: page titles, structured data, a sitemap, Search Console. You own the files and the domain, and you can take them anywhere.

The difference that matters most is not the design. It is that someone has thought about how a stranger decides whether to call you, and built the page around that.

Cost over three years

This is where the comparison usually surprises people. Rough numbers, in Australian dollars:

  • Builder: a business plan typically runs a few hundred dollars a year. Over three years, somewhere around $900 to $2,100 in subscriptions, plus however many of your own hours it takes.
  • Custom: a one page site from us starts at $1,490 and a full build runs $3,499 to $8,999. Hosting and upkeep on top is roughly $250 to $1,200 a year depending on whether you want someone looking after it.

So over three years the gap is smaller than the upfront numbers suggest, especially at the lower end. The real question is not which one is cheaper. It is which one brings in more work. One extra job a month usually pays for the difference several times over. We break the costs down further in what a website costs in Australia.

How to pick

A builder is probably right if:

  • The business is brand new and you are not sure it will last
  • You mostly need somewhere to point people to for your number and hours
  • You enjoy doing it yourself and have the time

Custom is probably right if:

  • You want the site to generate enquiries, not just exist
  • You are competing with other local businesses in search results
  • You have tried a builder and it is not bringing anything in
  • Your time is worth more on the tools than on a laptop
A builder gives you a website. It does not give you a reason for someone to ring.

Switching later

Plenty of businesses start on a builder and move to custom once the work picks up. That is a sensible path. When you do switch, keep your domain in your own name from day one, because that is the one thing you cannot easily get back.

Before you rebuild, read the redesign checklist so you do not lose whatever the old site has already built up in search. And if your current site gets visitors but no calls, these are the usual reasons, and several of them have nothing to do with the platform.

Not sure which way to go? Tell us what you do and what you have now. We will tell you honestly whether a builder is enough for you, and if it is, we will say so.

Skyfire Network

Western Sydney web design. Trade specialists, partner of Rated Tradies.